diff --git a/feps/fep-c118.md b/feps/fep-c118.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..7e62e0e --- /dev/null +++ b/feps/fep-c118.md @@ -0,0 +1,82 @@ +--- +authors: Tim Bray +status: DRAFT +dateReceived: 2023-01-16 +--- +# FEP-c118: Content licensing support + +## Summary + +Currently, popular Fediverse software does very little to establish the legal status of posts. +Controversy over indexing and scraping the Fediverse is common. +The hope is that providing a legal framework to express the desires of users as to how their content may be +re-used might bring order to this debate. + +## Scenario + +Dramatis Personae: +* A somewhat-technical new Fediverse arrival, hereinafter *Noob* +* Existing Fediverse Voices, hereinafer *EFV1*, *EFV2*, etc + +*Noob*: Hey, I want to crawl the Fediverse and build an index so we can… +*EFV1*: Stop! Go back! Don't! + +*EFV2*: We prefer not to do that here because we want to avoid into big-tech surveillance capitalism. + +*Noob*: But I mean they're all just URLs, right? + +*EFV3*: Burn the witch! + +*EFV4*: Unclean! + +*Noob*: Oh, I guess you don't want me to do this? + +*EFV5*: Never! + +*Noob*: Shouldn't you post the rules somewhere? I mean, lots of people are already doing this. + +*EFV6*: Defederate his instance! + +## Discussion + +This scenario is happening really a lot, multiple times per week in December/January 2022-3. + +At the moment, the Fediverse privacy story is unsatisfactory. Unless a user really understands the +visibility levels, every post they make instantly becomes part of the permanent indelible Internet +memory. There are no technical and very few legal barriers to prevent anyone from doing anything with +retrieved post content. + +In developed societies, when there are behaviors that are logistically possible but society would like +to regulate, legal tools are frequently applied. Examples would be dangerous driving and public smoking. + +A content-licensing framework for the Fediverse could include some or all of the following: + +1. Prevent access to posts without the accessor having somehow acknowledged the content license that applies. +2. Build a menu of content-license choices, probably starting from a Creative Commons basis. +3. One parameter of the content licenses should be temporal; i.e., license access to posts but only for two weeks (or some other interval). +4. Make it easy and straightforward for individuals posting to the Fediverse to pick a default content license for their posts, and also to apply other licensing choices to individual posts. +5. Arrange that when one user follows another, the following user must acknowledge the default content licensing options of the followed user. +6. Since most users will just take the defaults, each instance should carefully choose and prominently display its content-licensing defaults. + +I note that this document template comes with a carefully-considered Creative Commons license. Do not the contributions +of the humans who are enriching the Fediverse deserve a comparable level of protection? + +## Caveat + +Note that establishing a legal content-licensing framework will not prevent +certain bad actors from scraping the Fediverse and mis-using the harvested data. +That's OK because it will establish a legal framework that will present a significant barrier +to *commercial* data harvesters, and provide a tool to combat certain classes of mis-use. + +## See also: + +- Eugen Rochko, [Cage the Mastodon](https://blog.joinmastodon.org/2018/07/cage-the-mastodon/) in particular "Design Decisions" +- @pamela@bsd.network, [Hacky folks, please resist finding ways to scrape the fediverse….](https://bsd.network/@pamela/109287805657081451) +- GitHub discussion, [Controlling availability to search](https://github.com/w3c/activitypub/issues/221) +- Tim Bray [Private and Public Mastodon](https://www.tbray.org/ongoing/When/202x/2022/12/30/Mastodon-Privacy-and-Search) + +## Copyright + +CC0 1.0 Universal (CC0 1.0) Public Domain Dedication + +To the extent possible under law, the authors of this Fediverse Enhancement Proposal have waived all copyright and related or neighboring rights to this work.